Closed meeting called to discuss regional water issues; affected residents to be informed later
By J.C. Huntington
Dateline: Phoenix Arizona, Tuesday, March 13, 2001
Updated: March 22, 2001

A closed meeting described by the organizers as "the opening of a discussion on water between professionals and the affected residents of the region" was held March 13 at Biosphere II. 

Affected residents and the local press were not allowed to attend. 

According to the meeting organizers, the information gathered at the meeting will be disseminated to affected residents and the press sometime in the future 

Oracle residents Ann Woodin and Linda Leigh organized the meeting.  Leigh is affiliated with The Drylands Institute (www.drylands.org) and with the Center for Sustainable Prosperity (www.sustainableProsperity.org). 

Woodin chose to list her affiliation as Oracle Town Hall Planning Committee, even though Planning Committee members and a number of other residents had requested that she not do so as there had never been a vote by any Town Hall committee to sponsor the meeting.

A participant reported Pinal County deputies provided security services and stood guard outside the meeting room door. A professional videographer was hired to tape the proceedings and lunch was served.

Interested residents submitted questions for the participants and most were accepted by the organizers.  One question was not accepted and the submitter was told that the question would be best asked at a subsequent meeting of "planners and hydrologists."  The question follows:

Acknowledging the fact that Tucson is exhausting its own and imported ground water supplies, and is now in the process of converting to the use of Central Arizona Project water, do you believe that this rural area can be developed on Tucson's model of golf courses and high density housing projects without depleting the ground water?
A participant allowed in the meeting reported that Errol Montgomery told the assembly that depletion of the local aquifer might not be so bad if it brings economic prosperity, because the community could then afford to bring CAP water to replenish the aquifer. Montgomery is a hydrologist hired by the developers of the Willow Springs Ranch.

As of press time, the organizers of the meeting have chosen to not disclose their source(s) of funding for the meeting. 

Several invitees refused to attend the May 13 meeting and others, who asked to attend, were refused.

Invited participants choosing to attend were: 
 
 
Alex Argueta:
The Remington Group (hired by Anam Inc. to facilitate development of Willow Springs Ranch)
Charlie Deans
:
Planners Ink (a planning firm hired by Remington for the Willow Springs Ranch development)
Errol L. Montgomery
:
Errol L. Montgomery & Associates (a firm hired by Remington to assist with the Willow Springs development)
Mark Cross:
Errol L. Montgomery & Associates
Karl Polen:
Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Robson Communities Inc. (Polen was a last minute substitute for Jim Polus, another Robson executive.  Robson Communities SaddleBrooke Ranch development was recently delayed by a referendum initiated by affected residents)
Jan Wilson: 
Falcon Valley Ranch landowner
Steve Holland:
Director of Risk Management, University of Arizona (a number of local residents have complained to the Arizona Attorney General they believe Holland participated in illegally concealing test results confirming the Page-Trowbridge landfill is leaking to their water supply).
Peter Else
:
UA Campus Agricultural Center (in charge of the UA owned Page Ranch containing the Page-Ranch radioactive/toxic waste dump)
Jim Walters:
Arizona Department of Environmental Quality (informed of the alleged illegal act by Holland on 12/08/2000)
Jean Metzler
:
Arizona Department of Environmental Quality (informed of the alleged illegal act by Holland on 12/08/2000)
Kirk Creswick:
Arizona Department of Environmental Quality
Linda Stitzler:
Arizona Department of Water Resources
Dale Mason:
Arizona Department of Water Resources
Jim Livingstone:
Arizona Water Company
Michael Whitehead
Arizona Water Company
Charlie Clark:
Businessman, retired
Jean Schwennesen
Rancher, Winkelman Arizona
Cari Spring
Emerald Resource Solutions
Stan Leake:
U.S. Geological Survey
John McIver:
UA Advisory Committee for Page Trowbridge radioactive/toxic dump
Hector Conde:
UA Advisory Committee for Page Trowbridge radioactive/toxic dump
Robert Scarborough:
Arizona Desert Museum
Jane Garret:
Oracle Resident

Invitees that did not attend were:
 
Mary Ellen Kazda:
Oracle Town Hall Planning Committee
Web Parton:
Oracle Town Hall Page Ranch Committee
Cliff Russell:
Oracle Town Hall Page Ranch Committee
Cate McCarthy:
Pinal Citizens for Sustainable Communities
Reg Glos:
Pinal County Environmental Health
Dick McDaniels:
McDaniels Wells
Eric Schwennesen
Rancher, Winkelman Arizona
Jamie Argueta:
The Remington Group

Those that asked to attend, but were refused:
 
J.C. Huntington:
The Oracle newspaper
Steve Robson:
Robson Communities, Inc.


Use The 'Back' Button On Your Browser
To Return To Previous Page

News & Information
Introduction
Radiation Symbol
email:mekazda@mindspring.com